| First Eleven | Second Eleven | Third Eleven | Fourth Eleven | Sunday XI | Sunday 2nd XI | Midweek XI | Thursday XI | Ladies XI |
| 1909 E Henson | ||||||||
| 1874 O Mason | 1910-1911 E. Bird | |||||||
| 1877-1879 F Underwood | 1923 R Holyoak |
|||||||
| 1880 B Elliott | 1928 D Peberdy | |||||||
| 1882 A.H. Richardson | 1929-1930 A Ringrose | |||||||
| 1883 F Brown | 1931 D Peberdy | |||||||
| 1885 F Underwood | 1932 E W Smith | |||||||
| 1889 F.J. Loveday | 1933-1936 T A Sedgley | |||||||
| 1890-1909 C.B. Marriott | 1937-1938 W Dalton | |||||||
| 1910-1911 H.H. Marriott | 1939 V Lee | |||||||
| 1921-1922 T H Lewis | No 2nd XI fielded during WWII | 1921 Mr Whitlock | ||||||
| 1923 C.W. Berry | 1948-1957 R Dunn | |||||||
| 1924-1926 A.Knapp | ||||||||
| 1928 W.W. Partridge | 1958-1959 W East | |||||||
| 1929 J. Jesson | 1961-1962 R Beet | |||||||
| 1930-1931 C.W. Berry | 1964 D Lawrence | |||||||
| 1932-1949 E.W. Welton | 1965 J Ravenhill | |||||||
| 1950-1951 C.T. Iliffe | 1967 R Chandler | |||||||
| 1952 W.Garner | 1969-1971 J Wade | 1965 L Sturgess | ||||||
| 1953-1955 C.T. Iliffe | 1972 R Green | 1967 G Lee | ||||||
| 1956-1960 D.Symes | 1973 J Edwards | 1969-1972 R Beet | ||||||
| 1961-1963 D.W. Garner | 1974-1975 J.R Gilson | 1973 C Tory | ||||||
| 1964-1967 R.W. Beet | 1976 D Lawrence | 1974 R Beet | ||||||
| 1968-1971 L. Sturgess | 1979 J R Gilson | 1975 1976 G Webb | ||||||
| 1972-1973 D.W. Garner | 1980 R Beet | 1979-1981 D W Garner | ||||||
| 1974-1978 G. Lee | 1981 B Hollis | 1982 D Collins | ||||||
| 1979 J. Lucas | 1982 D Lawrence | 1983 T Cloke | ||||||
| 1980-1981 G. Lee | 1983-1986 C Freeman | 1984 L Sturgess | ||||||
| 1982-1983 R. Cuthbertson | 1987 L Sturgess | 1985 D Collins | 1986 C Tory | |||||
| 1984-1986 T. Cloke | 1988-1991 G Lee | 1986-1988 R Poyner | 1987 G Lee | |||||
| 1987 P. Dundas | 1992 J Lucas | 1989 G Clarke | 1988 D Gadsby | |||||
| 1988-1990 R. Nicholson | 1993-1995 J Peat | 2002 D. Collins | 1990-1992 D Lawrence | 1989 L Holmes | ||||
| 1991 J. Peat | 1996-1998 M King | 2003-2004 M.King | 1993 S Matthew | 1990 J Peat | ||||
| 1992 P.Higgs | 1999 J Waterfield | 2005-2006 J.S. Bleby | 1994-1995 J S Bleby | 1985-1992 J Armitage | 1991-1996 P Abbott | |||
| 1993-1994 P. Booth | 2000 - 2002 D Pedley | 2007- 2009 D. Pedley | 2006 S. Charles | 1996-2004 S Thompson | 1993-1995 G Bayes | 1997-1998 D Pedley | ||
| 1995-2003 R.A. Cobb | 2003 - 2009 D. Pounds | 2010 D Greenhalgh | 2007 W. Jennings | 2005- 2007 D Pedley | 1996-1998 P Illingworth | 1999-2004 K Folley | ||
| 2004-2006 M.D.R. Sutliff | 2010 S Matthew | 2011 M Wilkins | 2008- 2009 M.King | 2008 G Gibson | 1999 R Poyner | 2005-2008 D Pedley | ||
| 2007- 2011 A.P. Smith | 2011 - 2012 T Bailey | 2012 - C Hill | 2010 M Wilkins |
2009 - 2010 W Jennings | 2003 R Barkworth | 2009 - 2012 T Bailey | ||
| 2012 - 2016 M Craven | 2013 C Hill | 2013 - 2014 D Greenhalgh | 2011 - 2016 T Neal | 2012 K Folley | 2004 J S Bleby | 2013 D Broughton | ||
| 2017 - 2019 S Patel | 2014 - 2015 L Spence | 2015 - 2016 J Boucher | 2017 - 2019 S Munden | 2013 None appointed | 2014 C Newby | |||
| 2020 D Shaw | 2016 R Jackson | 2017 - 2018 K Messenger | 2020 J Hanger | 2014 I Blunt | 2015 - 2016 J Peel | |||
| 2017 L Spence | 2019 L Joel | 2015 - P Scott | 2017 - Charles Page Morris | 2015- S Walsh | ||||
| 2018 - R Patel | 2020 S Pounds |